It's possible that Dutch and the others genuinely thought that John was dead, ignoring the small chance that he might not be alive and thus abandoning him. This would mean that Javier was telling the truth in El Presidio. Without seeing John being left to die, we can't fully know the circumstances of it.
Nonetheless, can John Marston sleep at Beecher's Hope?
Beecher's Hope also has a number of places to explore. The house itself features rooms for Jack, Uncle's attic, John and Abigail's bedroom, a bathroom, and living and dining area. Some of these rooms have some different functionality. The bedroom for John and Abigail will let you fast travel, as well as sleep.
So anyway, will there be a rdr3? Red Dead Redemption 2 was a monumental video game. Expectations were sky high for its release, considering the pedigree of developer Rockstar Games and the quality of Red Dead Redemption. ... Though the series has proven a smash success, it seems unlikely you will see Red Dead Redemption 3.
Either, is Jack really Arthur's son?
Jack is actually Arthur's son. ... John is very sentimental about everything that Arthur did for him, he keeps the pictures of his family and even proposes to Abigail using the ring that he would have used to propose to the woman that would have been his wife.
Why did Dutch leave Arthur to die?
If the player was honorable, Dutch will leave because he is unable to choose between them. After which, Micah leaves in anger, while Arthur dies of his tuberculosis as he watches the sun rise from the mountainside. ... In this case, what happens is that Arthur abandons John in order to go back to the gang's burning camp.